.svg)
You're sitting in a renewal meeting. Your broker slides two proposals across the table.
Plan A costs $8 less per employee per month than Plan B.
For a company with 50 enrolled employees, that's nearly $5,000 a year in savings. It seems like an easy decision.
Then six months later...
- Several employees discover their primary care physician isn't in the network.
- Prescriptions cost more than expected.
- HR spends hours answering questions and helping employees navigate billing issues.
Suddenly, that $5,000 in savings doesn't feel like much of a win.
Choosing a medical plan isn't like buying office supplies. The lowest premium doesn't always deliver the greatest value.
During your health insurance renewal, it's tempting to focus on only one thing: the premium. After all, health insurance is one of the largest expenses most employers face. But a renewal should be evaluated on much more than the monthly cost. Choosing a medical plan based solely on the renewal percentage or monthly premium can overlook other costs that affect both your organization and your employees throughout the year.
Look Beyond the Renewal Increase
A plan with a lower monthly premium may also come with:
- Higher deductibles
- Higher out-of-pocket maximums
- Narrower provider networks
- Higher prescription drug costs
- Increased employee payroll deductions
- More prior authorization requirements
Lower premiums often come with tradeoffs that aren't immediately obvious.
Instead of paying higher premiums each month, employees may pay more when they actually need care, while HR may spend more time answering questions and resolving issues. Those tradeoffs don't make a lower-cost plan the wrong choice—but they should be part of the conversation before a decision is made.
Cost is only one part of the equation. In some cases, paying slightly more at renewal provides access to programs and services that improve employee wellbeing, encourage preventive care, or reduce the administrative burden on HR. Some carriers bundle additional resources such as Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs), wellness resources, telehealth services, health coaching, fitness or wellness incentives, and employee rewards programs.
Sometimes paying an additional one or two percent at renewal provides access to tools and resources that improve employee wellbeing, encourage preventive care, or reduce the administrative burden on HR.
The Employee Experience Matters
Health insurance is one of the most visible benefits an employer provides. While employees may not pay close attention during Open Enrollment, they notice when they receive an unexpected medical bill, can't see their preferred doctor, or discover a prescription costs much more than they anticipated.
When benefits become difficult to use or significantly more expensive, employees often turn to HR for answers. That can lead to frustration for everyone involved—even if the employer selected the plan with the best intentions. It can also contribute to financial stress, delayed care, and reduced employee satisfaction—issues that can affect engagement and productivity over time.
A renewal decision shouldn't only answer the question, "What will this cost the company?" It should also consider, "What will this experience be like for our employees?"
Don't Overlook the Carrier Experience
The insurance plan itself is only part of the equation. The carrier behind the plan can have just as much impact on your day-to-day experience. Two plans may look nearly identical on paper, but the experience of working with the carrier can be dramatically different.
We've worked with employers who chose to move away from a lower-cost carrier because ongoing administrative issues outweighed the savings. Billing errors, delayed enrollments, slow customer service, and difficulty resolving claims can consume valuable time for HR and create unnecessary frustration for employees.
Those challenges don't always show up in a renewal spreadsheet, but they can have a meaningful impact throughout the year.
When comparing renewal options, it's worth asking questions like:
- How responsive is the carrier's customer service?
- How easy is it to resolve enrollment or billing issues?
- Does the carrier provide tools that make administration easier?
- What has our experience with this carrier been over the past year?
Sometimes paying a little more for a better service experience saves time, reduces frustration, and ultimately provides more value.
Consider the Full Picture
The best health insurance renewal is the one that balances affordability, employee needs, administrative efficiency, and long-term value.
As you evaluate your options, consider questions like:
- Are employees able to keep the providers they rely on?
- How much additional cost is being shifted to employees?
- Will employees understand how to use the plan?
- How much additional work will this create for HR?
- Does this carrier provide the level of service we expect?
- Does this option align with our overall benefits strategy?
Looking beyond the premium often leads to better long-term decisions.
The Bottom Line
Cost will always be an important part of a renewal decision—and it should be. Employers have a responsibility to manage benefit expenses responsibly.
But the least expensive renewal on paper isn't always the one that delivers the greatest value over the course of the year. The strongest benefits strategies balance affordability with employee experience, administrative efficiency, provider access, and long-term stability.
At Royal Benefits Group, we help employers evaluate more than just renewal percentages. We look at provider access, employee experience, carrier performance, and long-term value so you can make informed decisions that support your employees, your HR team, and your business.
.svg)
